Carolina Hit on 22 of 23 Early Picks. Four Are Still Panthers.
Carolina turned 22 of 23 first and second round picks from 2012 through 2022 into 500-snap players, 95.7 percent against a league 88.6. Four of those hits are still on the roster.
NFL Roster Construction · GM Grading
An independent NFL publication grading every general manager's roster construction. Open data, snap-weighted, all 32 teams since 2012.
We grade every NFL general manager. Hit rate, retention, position construction, and the franchise pick. Snap-weighted across all 32 teams since 2012, all data public, all methodology open-source.
New analysis on Tuesdays. No sponsors. No paywalls.
Featured
Carolina turned 22 of 23 first and second round picks from 2012 through 2022 into 500-snap players, 95.7 percent against a league 88.6. Four of those hits are still on the roster.
Recent articles
Chicago turned 10 of its 11 fifth-round picks from 2012 through 2022 into 500-snap players, 90.9 percent against a league 45.7, a better rate than its own first round.
Baltimore converted 67 of 103 picks into 500-snap players from 2012 through 2022, second best in the NFL, and hit on 34 of 62 Day 3 picks against a league rate of 41.0 percent.
Atlanta converted 50 of 78 picks into 500-snap players from 2012 through 2022, third best in the NFL. Its retention is league average, and four picks from the 2012-2020 decade are left.
Arizona's 2012-2022 Day 1-2 hit rate was 80.6 percent against a league mark of 82.0. Four of Steve Keim's 74 picks remain, and 27 of the 32 homegrown players on the 2025 roster came from three drafts.
What we grade
Four columns, one grade, every team since 2012.
Share of a GM's picks that crossed the 500-snap line in a regular season. Compared to the league baseline so a GM is not credited for drafting in a high or low era.
Share of those picks still on the current 53-man roster, raw and snap-weighted. Drafting a player and keeping them are different skills.
Distribution of homegrown players across position groups, read against the team's identity. A defense-first roster carried by drafted defenders scores higher than one carried by free agents.
The single bet that defines the regime, usually the quarterback. Did it hit? A regime built around a missed franchise pick reads differently from one built around a hit.
Coming next
Next up: Bengals. Then Browns. New analysis on Tuesdays.